Indianapolis Real Estate Index

Contact Red Door Real Estate

If you have any questions or need more detailed information, please feel free to contact me via phone at 317-RED-DOOR / 317-733-3667 or fill out the form to let us know how we can help with your real estate needs.

Phone: (317) 733-3667
Fax: (317) 663-0840

Refine your search...
Use the form below to narrow down your results
Hi There! Is this Your First Time?

Did you know if you Register you have access to free search tools including the ability to save listings and property searches? Did you know that you can bypass the search altogether and have listings sent directly to your email address? Check out our how-to page for more info.

Back to Results
$649,900 -

909 E 58th Street Indianapolis IN 46220

4
Bedrooms
2
Baths
N/A
SQ. Feet
(Above Ground)
0.18
Acres

Welcome to 909 E 58th Street, nestled on a peaceful street in the heart of sought-after Forest Hills. This 4 bedroom, 2 bath home offers over 3,200 square feet of timeless character blended with modern comfort. Listed on the National Register of Historic Places, this residence is full of charm, thoughtful updates, and original hardwood floors throughout. Step onto the inviting covered front porch and into a beautifully updated kitchen featuring granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, ample cabinet storage, barstool seating, and additional appliance and beverage station for added convenience. The designated dining room showcases a chandelier and opens to a screened-in porch through elegant French doors, creating seamless indoor-outdoor living. The main level features two generous sized bedrooms, one of which is currently used as an office with warm wood paneling and built-ins, offering flexibility as a den or additional bedroom. The spacious great room includes a fireplace and is filled with natural light. A wrought iron railing leads to the upper level. Upstairs, one bedroom features a walk-in closet, charming dormer window, and a cozy sitting area. A second upstairs bedroom adds flexibility. Both rooms are served by a full bathroom on the upper level. The lower level includes a second fireplace, large bonus room, and abundant storage. Outdoors, the fenced backyard features a composite deck and paver patio, ideal for entertaining or enjoying quiet evenings. A two-car garage completes the property. Forest Hills is known for its unbeatable location and strong sense of community. You're just one block from the Monon Trail and within walking distance to Broad Ripple's restaurants, shops, and entertainment at The Vogue. Enjoy easy access to Fresh Thyme, Kroger, and Fresh Market. Seasonal highlights include dazzling fall foliage, a neighborhood-wide luminary display around winter holidays, and four annual block parties hosted just across the street.

Follow ►
  • Subscribe to Our Blog RSS
Read More...

Property Details

Price: $649,900 Previously: $649,900 Originally: $699,900 Bedrooms: 4 Bathrooms: 2.00 MLS #: 22046686 Year Built: 1940 Township: Washington Sq. Ft Total: 3,720 Type: Residential Zip Code: 46220 City: Indianapolis Subdivision: Forest Hills County: Marion School District: Indianapolis Public Schools

Interior Features

Interior Features:
  • Appliances: Dishwasher, Dryer, Disposal, MicroHood, Gas Oven, Refrigerator, Tankless Water Heater, Washer, Water Softener Owned
  • Cooling: Central Air
  • Heating: Natural Gas

Exterior Features

Exterior Features:
  • Setting / Lot Description: Mature Trees
  • Porch: Deck, Screened
  • # Acres: 0.18

Listing Office: F.c. Tucker Company

Similar Properties To: 909 E 58th Street, Indianapolis

$485,000
4 br, 2½ ba, 2,654 ft²
State Square
MLS® #:
21978563
Provider:
Crossroads Real Estate Group Llc
421 S Randolph Street, Indianapolis
$549,900
3 br, 2½ ba, 2,740 ft²
S A Fletcher Jr North East
MLS® #:
22046065
Provider:
Highgarden Real Estate
2008 Yandes Street, Indianapolis
$456,500
3 br, 3½ ba, 2,100 ft²
Meyers
MLS® #:
22030322
Provider:
Matlin Realty, Inc
1026 St Peter Street, Indianapolis
$619,900
4 br, 4 ba, 4,884 ft²
Lights Melrose
MLS® #:
22037609
Provider:
Re/max Elite Properties
1530 E 75th Street, Indianapolis
$535,000
4 br, 3½ ba, 4,181 ft²
Admirals Pointe
MLS® #:
22045333
Provider:
F.c. Tucker Company
12040 Kingfisher Circle, Indianapolis
$675,000
3 br, 2½ ba, 3,229 ft²
Subdivision Not Available See Legal
MLS® #:
22047478
Provider:
Monteith-legault Real Estate C
9451 Lafayette Road, Indianapolis
$557,000
4 br, 3 ba, 2,619 ft²
No Subdivision
MLS® #:
22034752
Provider:
The Real Estate Alternative
5135 N Kenwood Avenue, Indianapolis
$544,900
4 br, 3½ ba, 3,000 ft²
Boswell & Flemings Grandview Add
MLS® #:
22016643
Provider:
F.c. Tucker Company
2829 Macpherson Avenue, Indianapolis

View all similar properties here

All information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties that a consumer may be interested in purchasing. All Information believed to be reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2025 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative®. All rights reserved.

Listing information last updated on September 11th, 2025 at 6:55am EDT.

My Account

Log in, to view your saved searches and add to your favorite listings.

Sign Up Here For Your FREE Account

... So You Can:

  • View detailed property information
  • Print detailed property flyers
  • Save your searches & favorite homes
  • Inquire about a private showing
  • Map individual property locations
  • Share your favorite homes with friends
Interested In This Property?